Our Services

Book time for a 30-minute free of charge dispute consultation.

  • HMRC voluntary disclosure refers to the process by which taxpayers proactively inform HMRC about any errors or omissions in their tax affairs before HMRC discovers them. Making a voluntary disclosure can result in more favourable treatment, including reduced penalties and interest charges. It is an important step for individuals or businesses who have underreported income, claimed incorrect tax reliefs, or made other tax inaccuracies. Voluntary disclosure demonstrates cooperation and a willingness to comply with tax obligations, which HMRC views positively when determining penalties.

  • HMRC COP9 is a formal notice issued by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) as part of the Customs Offences Penalties (COP) regime. It serves as a warning letter to businesses or individuals suspected of committing customs offences, such as misdeclaration or non-payment of customs duties. The COP9 notice sets out the details of the suspected offence, provides the recipient with an opportunity to respond or make representations, and outlines the potential penalties that may follow if the issue is not resolved.

    Receiving a COP9 is a serious matter, signalling that HMRC is considering enforcement action. The recipient should carefully review the allegations, seek professional advice if necessary, and respond by the deadline stipulated in the notice to avoid further penalties or legal consequences. This process is designed to ensure compliance with customs regulations and the accurate payment of duties.

  • The HMRC Contractual Disclosure Facility (CDF) is a retroactive disclosure scheme introduced to allow taxpayers to declare previously unreported offshore income and gains voluntarily. It offers a structured process for individuals and businesses to regularise their tax affairs relating to offshore matters, reducing the risk of criminal investigation and heavy penalties.

    Under the CDF, taxpayers agree to disclose all relevant offshore income and gains for a specified period, typically going back up to 20 years. In return, HMRC grants immunity from prosecution for deliberate tax evasion on those periods, provided the disclosure is complete and accurate. The facility also offers reduced penalties compared to those that might be imposed if non-compliance were discovered through investigation.

    The CDF provides a legal framework for resolving offshore tax cases with certainty, offering a more controlled and less adversarial alternative to HMRC investigations. It is designed to promote compliance and restore confidence in the taxpayer’s affairs, while enabling HMRC to recover unpaid taxes efficiently.

  • HMRC COP8 refers to the HM Revenue & Customs Code of Practice 8, which outlines the procedures and guidelines HMRC follows when collecting tax debts. It is primarily concerned with the enforcement of outstanding tax liabilities in a fair, consistent, and transparent manner.

    The Code of Practice 8 sets out the steps HMRC takes when recovering unpaid taxes, including the use of continuous payment authorities, direct deductions from bank accounts, and other recovery actions. It ensures taxpayers are treated fairly and provides a framework for resolving debt issues while allowing for discussions on payment arrangements or disputes.

    COP 8 underscores the importance of early engagement with HMRC to manage tax debts and avoid enforcement measures. It also highlights taxpayers' rights and responsibilities throughout the collection process, aiming to balance effective debt recovery with fairness and compliance.

  • The HMRC Worldwide Disclosure Facility (WDF) is a compliance initiative designed to encourage individuals and businesses to disclose previously undeclared offshore income and gains voluntarily. It allows taxpayers who hold or have held assets or income outside the UK to come forward and regularise their tax affairs by declaring foreign income, gains, or assets that were not previously reported to HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC).

    The facility offers a structured and controlled process for making a full disclosure and paying any tax, interest, and penalties due. By doing so, taxpayers can significantly reduce the risk of criminal investigation or higher penalties associated with deliberate tax evasion. The WDF is part of HMRC’s broader commitment to tackling offshore tax evasion and aligns with international efforts to improve tax transparency.

    Taxpayers considering using the WDF should seek professional advice to ensure compliance with all requirements and to manage the disclosure process effectively. The facility remains an important tool for resolving offshore tax issues in a cooperative manner with HMRC.

  • HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) uses the concepts of residence and domicile to determine an individual’s liability to UK tax.

    Residence
    Residence status is determined primarily by the Statutory Residence Test (SRT). This involves assessing an individual’s physical presence in the UK during the tax year, alongside factors such as ties to the UK (accommodation, family, work). The test categorises individuals as either resident or non-resident. An individual who is resident in the UK is generally liable to UK tax on their worldwide income and gains.

    Domicile
    Domicile is a more subjective, long-term concept relating to the country that an individual considers their permanent home. It is not necessarily the same as residence or nationality. Domicile affects tax treatment, particularly concerning inheritance tax and the remittance basis of taxation. Most individuals will have a UK domicile if they were born in the UK with a UK domicile of origin and have not acquired a domicile of choice elsewhere. Domicile status can influence tax liabilities, especially for those with income or gains arising outside the UK.

    Understanding both residence and domicile is crucial for correct tax planning and compliance with HMRC requirements.

    Please note, as of 6th April 2025, the concept of domicile status has been abolished and a new residence-based regime has been implemented.

    Despite this change, Thistle Tax can still assist with historic enquiries.

  • HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) employment status determines how an individual should be classified for tax and National Insurance purposes. The classification impacts whether a worker is considered employed or self-employed, which in turn affects tax withholding, National Insurance contributions, and employment rights.

    If HMRC determines that a worker is employed, the employer must operate PAYE (Pay As You Earn) to deduct income tax and National Insurance contributions before payment. Conversely, if the worker is self-employed, they are responsible for reporting their income and paying tax through Self Assessment.

    Employment status is a complex area with significant tax implications, and HMRC provides guidance and tools, such as the Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool, to assist in determining the correct status. Misclassification can lead to additional tax liabilities, interest and penalties. It is vital that accurate assessment is performed to minimise disputes with HMRC.

  • Managed Service Companies (MSCs) are arrangements where contractors provide their services through a company that is managed by a third party, often a specialist management company. These companies typically handle administrative tasks such as invoicing, payroll, and tax deductions on behalf of the contractors.

    HMRC views such arrangements with scrutiny due to concerns over tax avoidance and non-compliance. The main issue arises when the management company operates in a manner similar to an employer, deducting tax and National Insurance contributions under the Pay As You Earn (PAYE) system before paying contractors, effectively treating them as employees for tax purposes.

    To address this, HMRC introduced the Managed Service Company (MSC) legislation, which determines whether a company falls within the MSC rules. If a company is classified as an MSC, the income payments to contractors are subject to PAYE tax and National Insurance contributions, regardless of the contractor's employment status or whether dividends are issued.

    The legislation aims to prevent contractors from avoiding PAYE tax and National Insurance by using management companies as intermediaries. Companies operating as MSCs have increased compliance obligations, and contractors working through these entities must understand the tax implications and their responsibilities.

    In summary, Managed Service Companies are intermediary organisations managing the engagement and payments of contractors, with specific tax rules applied to ensure proper deduction of PAYE and National Insurance contributions to counteract tax avoidance schemes.

  • HMRC personal service companies (PSCs) are limited companies through which an individual provides services to clients, typically on a contract basis. The individual usually works under their own control and direction, but the services are supplied via the company rather than as a direct employee.

    HMRC focuses on PSCs primarily in connection with IR35 legislation, which aims to determine whether a contractor is genuinely self-employed or operating as a disguised employee. If a PSC worker falls inside IR35, the income earned through the company is treated as employment income for tax purposes, and appropriate income tax and National Insurance contributions must be deducted.

    HMRC applies tests regarding control, substitution, and mutuality of obligation to ascertain employment status. When deemed inside IR35, the PSC must ensure accurate tax compliance, which impacts how profits are drawn from the company.

    It is essential for PSCs to carefully consider IR35 status on each contract to avoid unexpected tax liabilities and penalties. Professional advice is often necessary to assess the risk and manage compliance effectively.

  • HMRC IR35 is legislation introduced to determine the employment status of individuals working through intermediaries, such as personal service companies, for tax purposes. Its primary aim is to identify disguised employment, where a contractor operates in a similar manner to an employee but benefits from the tax advantages of self-employment. If caught by IR35, the individual is deemed an employee for tax and National Insurance purposes, requiring the payment of income tax and National Insurance contributions as if they were on the payroll. The responsibility for determining IR35 status can fall on the engager, agency, or worker depending on the sector and contract. Compliance with IR35 is essential to avoid penalties and ensure correct tax treatment.

  • HMRC Tax Litigation Service provides a specialised support framework for taxpayers involved in disputes with HM Revenue and Customs. This service assists individuals and businesses facing investigations, appeals, or litigation related to tax assessments, penalties, and compliance issues.

    The service includes expert representation and advice throughout the dispute resolution process, ensuring that clients’ rights are protected and their cases are presented effectively. The objective is to resolve matters efficiently, whether through negotiation, mediation, or formal court proceedings.

    Clients benefit from detailed guidance on procedural requirements, preparation of documentation, and strategic planning to minimise financial exposure and reputational risks. The HMRC Tax Litigation Service operates with a focus on achieving fair outcomes while maintaining compliance with relevant tax laws and regulations.

  • HMRC personal tax investigations are formal enquiries conducted by HMRC into an individual’s personal tax affairs. These investigations aim to verify the accuracy and completeness of the tax returns submitted and ensure the correct amount of tax has been paid.

    Investigations may arise from discrepancies in tax returns, third-party information, or random selection. HMRC can review various aspects, including income, expenses, capital gains, and inheritance tax declarations.

    During an investigation, individuals are required to provide evidence supporting their tax calculations, such as bank statements, invoices, contracts, and receipts. HMRC can request access to extensive financial records and may ask for interviews or additional information.

    The process can result in adjustments to tax liabilities, penalties, and interest charges if inaccuracies or deliberate errors are found. Cooperation and transparency can influence the outcome, possibly reducing penalties.

  • HMRC company tax investigations occur when HMRC reviews a company’s tax affairs to ensure compliance with tax laws. These investigations can arise from random checks, risk profiling, or specific triggers such as discrepancies in tax returns or third-party information.

    The process typically begins with a formal notification from HMRC, detailing the scope of the investigation. Companies may be required to provide extensive documentation, including financial records, accounting statements, and correspondence. HMRC aims to verify the accuracy of declared income, expenses, VAT returns, corporation tax payments, and other relevant tax obligations.

    During the investigation, HMRC may request meetings with company directors, finance personnel, or external advisers to clarify issues. The company is entitled to respond to findings and present supporting evidence. The duration of investigations can vary widely, depending on the complexity and scope of the enquiry.

    If discrepancies or errors are identified, HMRC may seek additional tax payments, impose penalties, and request interest on overdue amounts. In serious cases involving deliberate evasion, criminal proceedings could follow.

  • HMRC partnership tax investigations involve a detailed examination of a partnership's tax affairs to ensure compliance with UK tax laws. These investigations can be triggered by inconsistencies in tax returns, discrepancies identified through data matching, third-party information, or routine compliance checks.

    During an investigation, HMRC scrutinises partnership income, expenses, distributions, and the correct reporting of profits by individual partners. The focus is on verifying that the partnership’s tax returns are accurate and that partners have declared income correctly on their personal tax returns.

    The process typically includes the review of accounting records, bank statements, invoices, and correspondence. HMRC may request explanations for particular transactions or adjustments and can interview partners or representatives. If errors or deliberate tax avoidance are identified, HMRC can impose penalties and interest on unpaid tax.

  • HMRC VAT tax investigations are formal enquiries conducted by HMRC to ensure that a business’ Value Added Tax (VAT) returns and payments are accurate and comply with tax legislation. These investigations typically arise when HMRC identifies discrepancies, irregularities, or suspicious patterns in a business’s VAT records.

    During a VAT investigation, HMRC may request detailed documentation, including VAT returns, invoices, purchase and sales records, and accounting books. The process involves a thorough examination of these records to verify that the correct amount of VAT has been charged, collected, and remitted.

    Investigations can vary in scope—ranging from limited enquiries focusing on specific transactions to full-scale enquiries covering multiple tax periods. The duration of an investigation depends on its complexity and the responsiveness of the business.

    If errors, underpayments, or fraudulent activities are uncovered, HMRC may impose penalties and interest charges in addition to requiring the payment of any outstanding VAT. Businesses subject to investigation are advised to seek professional advice promptly to manage the process effectively and ensure compliance with tax obligations.

  • HMRC offshore tax investigations involve the systematic examination of individuals and businesses suspected of failing to declare income, gains, or assets held outside the UK. These investigations are typically initiated when HMRC identifies discrepancies through data received from foreign tax authorities, whistleblowers, or intelligence gathered by their Compliance and Enforcement teams.

    The objective of an offshore tax investigation is to establish whether taxpayers have fulfilled their legal obligations, including proper reporting and payment of all relevant taxes such as income tax, capital gains tax, and inheritance tax in relation to offshore assets or income streams.

    HMRC’s approach is rigorous and may include detailed requests for documentation, interviews, and analysis of financial records. They possess extensive powers to obtain information, including data-sharing agreements with overseas jurisdictions and the ability to levy penalties and interest on unpaid taxes. Penalties for non-compliance can be substantial, particularly if HMRC considers the failure to be deliberate or concealed.

    Taxpayers subject to an offshore investigation are advised to seek specialist advice promptly to ensure compliance, negotiate with HMRC where appropriate, and mitigate potential penalties. Voluntary disclosure under the Contractual Disclosure Facility (CDF) or other HMRC disclosure routes may be available before an investigation starts, offering reduced penalties.

    Ultimately, HMRC offshore tax investigations emphasise transparency and compliance with UK tax laws concerning offshore assets, reflecting the government’s broader commitment to tackling tax evasion and promoting fair taxation.

  • HMRC PAYE tax investigations involve a detailed examination conducted by HM Revenue and Customs to ensure compliance with Pay As You Earn (PAYE) regulations. These investigations focus on verifying that employers have correctly operated the PAYE system, accurately deducting and reporting income tax and National Insurance contributions from employees' earnings.

    During a PAYE tax investigation, HMRC reviews payroll records, employment contracts, and related documentation to assess whether the correct amount of tax and National Insurance has been collected and paid. The scope can include checking the accuracy of employee classification, payment of benefits in kind, expenses, and the application of statutory payments such as sick pay and maternity pay.

    HMRC may initiate an investigation based on a variety of triggers, including discrepancies found during routine compliance checks, employee complaints, or irregularities identified through data matching. Employers are required to cooperate fully, providing requested records and explanations within specified timeframes.

    If errors or non-compliance are identified, HMRC may impose penalties and require payment of outstanding tax and contributions. Penalty levels depend on the nature and severity of the offence, and whether the non-compliance was deliberate or due to carelessness. Early engagement with HMRC and voluntary disclosure of errors can mitigate penalties.

  • HMRC criminal tax investigations are formal inquiries conducted by HMRC to uncover and prosecute serious tax offences. These investigations typically arise when there is evidence or suspicion of deliberate tax evasion, fraud, false accounting, money laundering, or other criminal activities related to tax.

    The process involves detailed scrutiny of financial records, transactions, and conduct to establish whether a taxpayer has intentionally breached tax laws. HMRC’s Fraud Investigation Service (FIS) team, consisting of experienced investigators, accountants, and legal specialists, leads these cases. They work in collaboration with other law enforcement agencies when necessary.

    If sufficient evidence is gathered, HMRC may pursue prosecution, which can result in criminal charges, fines, penalties, and, in severe cases, imprisonment. The consequences of a criminal tax investigation are significant and can affect both individuals and businesses.

  • HMRC tax tribunals are independent judicial bodies that hear disputes between taxpayers and HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) regarding tax matters. These tribunals provide an impartial forum for resolving disagreements on various tax issues.

    The tribunal process allows taxpayers to challenge HMRC decisions without resorting to the higher courts initially, helping to reduce costs and offer a more specialised environment. Typically, cases begin at the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber), where facts and legal issues are examined. If a party is dissatisfied with the First-tier Tribunal’s decision, they may appeal to the Upper Tribunal on points of law.

    Tribunal hearings are less formal than courts, enabling taxpayers to represent themselves if they wish, although professional representation is often recommended due to the complexity of tax law. Decisions beyond Upper Tier Tribunal are legally binding and set important precedents for future tax disputes.

  • HMRC compliance checks are routine reviews conducted by HMRC to ensure taxpayers are correctly reporting their tax liabilities. These checks verify the accuracy of tax returns and supporting documentation submitted by individuals or businesses. The process typically involves examining financial records, invoices, bank statements, and other relevant documents.

    Compliance checks can vary in scope, ranging from simple enquiries to more detailed investigations if discrepancies or errors are suspected. HMRC may request additional information or explanations to clarify specific entries. If errors are identified, taxpayers may be required to amend their returns and could face penalties or interest charges depending on the severity of the issue.

Contact us

For further information or to speak with a member of the team, contact us today.